BWW Reviews: TROUBLE IN TAHITI Full of Promise and Proposals

By: Aug. 18, 2012
Get Access To Every Broadway Story

Unlock access to every one of the hundreds of articles published daily on BroadwayWorld by logging in with one click.




Existing user? Just click login.

The opening of Leonard Bernstein's TROUBLE IN TAHITI in Cape Town this week was cause for great excitement and justifiably so. Bernstein's opera gets less of an airing both here and internationally than it should, although it forms a part of Bernstein's later and altogether less successful work, A QUIET PLACE, and the debut collaboration between Cape Town Opera and the Fugard Theatre is also a relationship that promises great potential.

TROUBLE IN TAHITI was written by Bernstein in 1951, ostensibly based on the relationship between the composer's mother and father. The piece deals with a day in the life of a typically American husband and wife who have lost the connection they once had. While the piece deals with one of the cornerstones of the American Dream, the piece naturally has resonance far beyond the borders of the United States, as it deals with a universal human issue that is as relevant now, in a time where the debate around what constitutes a marriage has become a major human rights issue, as it was six decades ago.

With TROUBLE IN TAHITI, Matthew Wild, who directed a thrilling production of SUOR ANGELICA for Cape Town Opera last season, continues to breathe fresh air into Cape Town Opera, a company that far too often settles for productions that feel derivative when they aim for the traditional or gauche when they aim to be contemporary. In a land where the conductor is king, Wild makes an effective case that while monarchies might be ruled by royalty, they are more effectively governed by prime ministers. His work here is deft and convincing.

That said, the musical demands of Bernstein's score, under the leadership of conductor Alexander Fokkens and musical director Ean Smit, are served exceptionally well, with the seven piece orchestra bringing the eclectic mix of musical styles to life tightly and effusively.

As Sam and Dinah, Thato Machona and Violina Anguelov individually make fine work of Bernstein's material. Machona comes to the fore in the scenes in his office and at the gym, where his rich baritone wraps himself around the music in an almost hypnotic fashion. He juxtaposes Sam's confident public charisma with his personal struggle to connect with his wife effectively.

Anguelov's haunting delivery of Dinah’s confession of her dreams to her analyst effectively balances her delivery of the "What a Movie!" aria later in the opera, where she mines the material for both humour and pathos. She portrays efficaciously the frustrations of a woman caught up by the romance of possibility, but trapped by her circumstances and, more tragically, by her own behaviour.

The pair is less compelling in the scenes where the characters interact with one another, where they needed to play the dynamics of the relationship more vividly. A sequence like the one where Sam and Dinah run into each other in the city and lie to avoid spending time together should imbue within the audience the poignant regret felt by the characters as they become aware of what they are doing. The lack of chemistry between Machona and Anguelov, made all the more noticeable by the intimacy of the venue, makes moments such as these less effective than they could be.

The trio of commentators who observe the action as it plays out, sung by Nonhlanhla Yende, Lukhanyo Moyake and Owen Metsileng, are delightful. Their constant presence unifies the staging without being distracting and when they take centre stage, most effectively in the "Mornin' Sun" prelude, they infuse their performances with wit and brio. The moments when they play reactive roles like Sam's secretary and Dinah's analyst, wearing identical gimmick glasses (a neat design touch), are similarly pleasing.

Visually, the show has a sense of style that effectively recalls the 1950s, albeit one that is filtered through the sensibility of the way MAD MEN depicts the decade that followed. The costumes are fantastic and the cartoon like projections that appeared within the television-shaped box upstage centre matched the overall tone of the production well.

The spatial design of the stage is executed less successfully. The set was designed by Tina Driedijk to be used for performances in remote venues that are not necessarily traditional theatre spaces and here, in the Studio Theatre at the Fugard, it looks it. Furthermore, in a setup like this where the musicians are visible, greater care needs to be taken in regard to their positioning because they become a part of the design. They have to gel with what is going on visually. Here, squeezed tightly on one side of the stage, it feels as though someone is trying hide the orchestra in open view, an unsatisfying impossibility that does not have to be the problem it is at all.

To lengthen the performance into a full evening's entertainment, TROUBLE IN TAHITI is prefaced by a stylish lecture entitled "The Musical Marriages of Leonard Bernstein", which introduces the life and works of the composer. Hosted by Francis Chouler, with singers from the Cape Town Opera Voice of the Nation Studio performing songs from Bernstein's PETER PAN, WONDERFUL TOWN, WEST SIDE STORY and CANDIDE, the lecture works well because it is not a simple documentary oration, but one that is put together so as to connect with the thematic concerns that come to the fore in TROUBLE IN TAHITI itself. It is a pity that Chouler's cue cards for this segment of the evening could not have been dispensed with. He delivers the prose with such charm and this would only have been enhanced had he had the opportunity to play the raconteur rather than the reader.

TROUBLE IN TAHITI is well worth watching and makes for an engaging and thought-provoking night at the theatre. In marriage talk, it is an evening full of proposals that promise great things to come: from Cape Town Opera, from their collaboration with the Fugard Theatre and from Wild himself. Let us hope for an extended honeymoon and a relationship between these three collaborators that only extends in its depth and fruitfulness.

TROUBLE IN TAHITI runs at the Fugard Theatre Theatre in Cape Town until 18 August 2012. Tickets are available from Computicket.

 



Videos